
In Praise of Curiosity
Next month, in Sapir (Winter 2027) The New Jewish Academy’s President and CEO Avi Bernstein-Nahar speaks out against the veneration of Thomist philosopher and Great Books advocate, Mortimer Adler (1902 -2001).
Adler, who had converted to Roman Catholicism by the end of his life, made a great deal of what he and University of Chicago President Robert Maynard Hutchins called “the great conversation” about worthy books and ideas. Well and good!
Nevertheless, Adler, who was born in 1902 to a Manhattan-based Jewish family, seems, over the course of his long career engaging with “Great Books,” to have evinced little or no curiosity about the rich forms of shakla v’taryah* characteristic of the rabbinic tradition. Though one should perhaps feel compassion for Adler and his “ordeal” with the demands of civility, Bernstein-Nahar is indignant at the thought that Adler ought to be counted as a Jewish American deserving a place of honor in the story of American Jewish contributions to post-war liberalism.
Bernstein-Nahar’s letter, including a back-and-forth with Adam Bellow, a publisher in the “Jewish books” space, appears on the current Sapir website, and will also appear in SAPIR‘s next print edition.
*Shakla v’taryah (שַׁקְלָא וְטַרְיָא) is an Aramaic phrase meaning, roughly, “give and take.” It refers to the back-and-forth dialectical argumentation that is the hallmark of Talmudic discourse — the process of raising a question or challenge, offering a response, then raising a new difficulty, and so on.
The word shakla comes from the root meaning “to take/weigh,” and tarya from “to carry/bring.” Together they describe the motion of an argument being tossed back and forth, tested and refined.
Why It Matters
The shakla v’taryah is not incidental to the Talmud — it is the Talmud. Rather than presenting legal conclusions alone, the Gemara preserves the entire argumentative process: objections (kushyot), answers (tirutzim), proofs, refutations, and new questions. The journey of reasoning is considered as sacred as the destination.
This explanation of *Shakla v’taryah was provided by the “Library Assistant” on Sefaria‘s Talmud Introduction page.
